Prijava moderiranja na r/Ljubljana
Naposled je zloglasni nesmiselni ban doletel tudi mene, kar me je utečnobilo do te mere, da zdaj obstaja tale vodič – čeprav ga verjetno ne bo nihče prebral, kaj šele uporabil.
Za kaj gre?
V zadnjem času vedno več uporabnikov poroča o banih na r/Ljubljana in izkazalo se je, da gre za arbitrarno pravilo blokiranja vseh, ki so kadarkoli sodelovali na r/Slovenia. Čeprav je menda nekoč nek Reddit admin nekje objavil, da to ne krši Redditovih pravil, je njihov "ban message" generičen in vsebuje neresnične navedbe: trdijo namreč, da smo uporabniki s tem kršili pravila subreddita, a v resnici jih nismo, saj to ni nikjer eksplicitno omenjeno.
Zakaj je to še posebej bizarno? Zadnja leta, posebno pa v času umora Aleša Šutarja, se je na r/Slovenia pojavljalo ogromno objav, kako da je subreddit cenzuriran itd.; na neki točki je bil celo "ustavljen" za vse (oz. večino) uporabnikov. O upravičenosti tega početja tukaj ne gre razpravljati, se je pa ravno v tem času r/Ljubljana predstavljal kot "odprta alternativa", ki ne cenzurira ničesar, kjer so vsa mnenja in vsi prispevki dobrodošli, četudi niso v direktni povezavi z Ljubljano.
Update: V zadnji, tudi pripeti, objavi (Situacija) na r/Ljubljana (očitno novi) moderator omenja "avtomatski ban" na podlagi sodelovanja ne samo v r/Slovenia, temveč tudi v r/SloveniaPlumbingNSFW. Ali je bil bot res pomota, kot navedeno v objavi, ali ne, je drugo vprašanje – stari moderatorji so namreč ban pojasnjevali takole:
We decided to limit participation of users who are participating in other specific subreddits. We decided to do this because in the past we often got harassing and brigading from members of those subreddits.
We always had very clear rules regarding that but users always complained that we restrict their freedom of speech. While they were writing insults and racist content. We will not tolerate that.
Edit: bots were added by mods manually
Če se je ban zgodil tudi tebi in želiš to prijaviti na višji nivo (brez kontaktiranja moderatorjev), obstaja uradna pot: Moderator Code of Conduct report form. Redditov Moderator Code of Conduct ima eksplicitno naveden obrazec za prijavo. (Uspeh sicer seveda ni zagotovljen, ampak poskusiti ni greh.)
Kaj vključiti v prijavo?
- link do "ban sporočila"
- link do tvojega komentarja/objave v
r/Ljubljana - kopijo pravil
r/Ljubljana(ker v njih nikjer ni omenjeno "ban zaradi drugega subreddita") - (opcijsko) linki do drugih objav, kjer ljudje poročajo isto (kot dokaz za ponavljajoč se vzorec, ne osamljen primer)
Uradni obrazec
Report a Moderator Code of Conduct violation:
https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket_form_id=19300233728916
Angleška predloga
(v grobem verjetno tole zadostuje, linke seveda zamenjaj s svojimi)
Subject: r/Ljubljana — permanent ban without cited rule / suspected hidden rule enforcement
Text:
I am reporting the moderation team of r/Ljubljana for enforcing an undisclosed rule via permanent bans.
I received a permanent ban from r/Ljubljana. The ban message does not cite any specific rule that I violated (ban message link: [PASTE LINK]). I did not post NSFW content, advertising, harassment, spam, or anything unrelated to Ljubljana. I only replied to a comment/post (link: [PASTE LINK]).
This appears to violate the Moderator Code of Conduct, particularly Rule 2 (Set and Manage Reasonable Expectations) and Rule 5 (Moderation with Integrity). The published rules of r/Ljubljana do not mention bans based on participation in other subreddits. Despite that, users appear to be banned solely for having posted or commented inr/Slovenia(the main national community subreddit for Slovenia).
This looks like hidden rule enforcement and a systematic moderation practice rather than transparent, rule-based moderation.
Please review this for compliance with the Moderator Code of Conduct (especially Rules 2 and 5) and ensure moderation expectations are reasonable and clearly communicated.
Objavljeno: 19. 1. 2026
Posodobljeno: 22. 1. 2026